What a weaken question is asking

A weaken question gives you a short argument and asks you to pick the answer that makes that argument less believable. That is the whole job. You are not picking the answer you agree with. You are picking the one answer that, if it were true, would hurt this specific argument.

You will see stems worded in ways like these:

  • Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
  • Which one of the following, if true, most undermines the conclusion?
  • Which one of the following calls the argument into question?

Every answer gets tested as if it were a fact. You do not get to argue with it. If it is true and the conclusion gets weaker, it is doing the job. If the conclusion does not move, it is not.

Weaken does not mean destroy

Many students set the bar too high. They look for an answer that proves the conclusion false, find nothing that strong, and start guessing.

The right answer does not have to kill the argument. It only has to make the conclusion less likely than the evidence first made it seem. A good weaken answer might give another cause for the same result, show that a group is not typical, or show that something the plan depends on will not happen.

Four answers are very wrong and one is very right. The wrong ones hurt a different claim, help the argument by mistake, or talk about the right topic without touching the logic. The right one hits the link between the reasons and the conclusion.

A plain four step method

Step 1: Say the conclusion in plain words

Find the exact claim. Is it a cause, a prediction, a recommendation, or a judgment about a group? Say it back in one short sentence and keep that sentence in front of you. Most wrong answers on this type are wrong because they weaken something close to the conclusion but not the conclusion itself.

Step 2: Name the reasons and the link

Ask what reasons the author gives, and what link the author needs between those reasons and the claim. For a cause claim, the link is often that nothing else explains the result. For a recommendation, it is often that the plan will work as expected. Just name, in plain words, what has to hold for the reasons to support the claim.

Step 3: Predict the kind of hurt, not the exact words

Before you judge the choices, give yourself a rough idea of what a good attack would look like. You might think: another cause would hurt this, or a case where the plan failed would hurt this. Your prediction will not match the right answer word for word. It gives you a standard so you stop picking answers just because they sound negative.

Step 4: Test each answer the same way

For each choice, ask one question: if this is true, does the conclusion get less believable? Say yes, no, or the opposite. If an answer actually makes the conclusion more believable, cross it out at once. If it leaves the conclusion exactly where it was, cross it out too. Keep the answer that does real damage to the link you named in step 2.

Worked example: the repair shop

Here is a short argument made up for this guide:

A bike repair shop started offering a free safety check with every tune up in June. Tune up sales rose that month. The owner concludes that the free check caused the rise, so the shop should keep the offer all year.

The conclusion has two parts. The free check caused the June rise, and the shop should keep the offer. The main link is the cause claim. If something else caused the rise, the reason to keep the offer gets much weaker.

Now test some choices:

  • A road race held in town in June brought hundreds of extra riders to the shop that month. If this is true, does the conclusion get weaker? Yes. It gives another clear cause for more tune ups in June, and it explains why June was unusual. Keep it.
  • Some customers said they did not care about the free safety check. Does this hurt much? Only a little, if at all. Some customers not caring still leaves plenty who might have come for the check. Words like some are a common trap.
  • The shop also gave a free check with tune ups two years ago. Does this touch the June claim? No. What happened two years ago does not explain the rise this June. On topic, but it does no work.
  • Most customers who got a tune up in June said the free check was the main reason they booked. This does the opposite job. If true, it supports the owner. Cross out any answer that helps when the question asks you to hurt.

The first choice wins because it attacks the exact link. It does not prove the free check did nothing. It shows the rise could have happened for a different reason, and that is enough to weaken the argument.

The traps that catch most students

  • The opposite answer. It sounds strong and confident, but it supports the conclusion. Always check the direction before you check the strength.
  • The right topic, wrong claim. It hurts a side point or a stronger version of the argument that the author never made. Test it against the exact conclusion you wrote down.
  • True but useless. A choice can be plainly true and still change nothing. If the conclusion sits in the same place after you accept it, it is wrong for this question.
  • Too weak to matter. Words like some, a few, and occasionally can shrink an answer until it does almost no damage. Compare it with the answer that covers the main case in the argument.
  • A new complaint. It raises a cost the argument never depended on avoiding. A plan can have a downside and still be well supported.

How to practice this type

  1. Work untimed first. Write the conclusion and the link in plain words on every question until that habit is automatic.
  2. For each choice, mark one letter: W for weakens, S for strengthens, or N for does nothing. Do this before you pick a winner. The habit forces you to check direction.
  3. In review, write one line for the right answer that says why it is right, in terms of the link it breaks.
  4. For the answer you picked when you were wrong, write one line that says why it is wrong: wrong direction, wrong claim, too weak, or no effect.
  5. Redo the question a few days later without looking at your notes.

Weaken questions get easier once you stop hunting for the most negative sounding answer. Find the conclusion, name the link it stands on, and pick the answer that does real damage to that link. The rest are just noise in different shapes.