Find the argument with the same logical structure. Three original questions below. No timer. Check each answer and read the explanation before moving on.
Question 1
All lifeguards are strong swimmers. Maria is a lifeguard. Therefore, Maria is a strong swimmer.
Which of the following is most similar in its reasoning?
Show explanation
Both are textbook syllogisms: All A are B, X is A, so X is B. A reverses it, C generalizes from one case, D weakens a premise.
Question 2
The movie was either a comedy or a drama. It was not a comedy. So it was a drama.
Which of the following exhibits the same pattern of reasoning?
Show explanation
Both are disjunctive syllogisms: A or B, not A, therefore B. A affirms instead of denying; C is a conditional.
Question 3
Most successful startups have a technical founder. This startup has a technical founder. So it will probably succeed.
Which of the following follows the same flawed pattern?
Show explanation
Both confuse "most A are B" with "most B are A." Having the trait of successful things does not make success likely. The others change the structure.